Cambodia: “I seek my childhood like a lost picture” — Review of the Documentary The Missing Picture — The North Star Reports, sponsored by The Middle Ground Journal. By Cait Greeley
The Cambodian documentary, The Missing Picture, directed by Rithy Pahn, offers a terribly beautiful portrayal of a dark time in Khmer history. The title comes from the opening scene in the film, which features a room filled with old rolls of water-damaged film in rusted and deteriorated film cases. These rolls hold the history of the Khmer Rouge regime and its devastating impact on the people of Cambodia . It sets the stage for the rest of the movie as it reveals a lost time and voided past- a “missing picture.”
The scenes throughout the film consist of clay figurines placed into physical land features that include the presence of natural elements like water, rain, trees, and fields. The clay figurines are used as the actors in the film; I cannot determine if they are used to help lessen the horror story or if they actually heighten it. The film almost feels like it could be viewed by young children, yet it is dark enough for a mature audience. It was very imaginative on the director’s part to take an existing account of the horrific events that took place and making it more like fiction with the use of clay.
The artistic components of the film are stimulating, particularly the use of contrast. Many contrasts were seen all through the film: most notably, the contrast of fear and the hope-filled human heart were skillfully blended throughout the film. The main character’s yellow and red polka-dotted pink shirt, which represents his youthfulness, makes him stand out as the main character against the crowd of black shrouds. The contrast between life and death is represented in colors. Those cloaked in black were already dead, whereas the main character survived. The way in which the director contrasts the reality of the physical environment against the subtlety of the clay medium is especially noteworthy. One scene depicting fishing and rain stands out. After a rainstorm, the clay model figurines are drenched, dripping with real water. The ponds in which the clay figurines cast their reel have real fish swimming in them. In this way, perhaps, the director wants to remind the audience that the story being told is not merely a work of fiction, but reality.
Another significant scene contrasts the clay scenarios to actual footage being played in the film. In the clay hospital scenes, showing where people at the labor camps went to die, the trauma felt dimmed through the use of clay. However, the next scene uses actual footage of medical experimentation that the Khmer Rouge conducted on rats. The same extremely traumatic experiments were also used to torture people at the S21 extermination center.
The way in which Rithy conveyed emotion was compelling. Throughout the film, the mood shifts from bitter sweetness, noted in the use of bright colors, to a somber, uniform sea of black with everyone having the same ghastly look on their faces. As the colors faded out, the mood was heightened by the presence of real life footage taken from the Khmer Rouge. Interestingly, the camera man who took the footage was killed yet the footage remains. The black-and-white footage serves as gloomy backdrop against the clay figures. All the while, the mood shifts in the music, alternating from joyful to haunting with the bellow sounds of the cello and wails of various stringed instruments. As the narrator in the film states, “soon there will be no more love. Soon there will be no more emotion, and even words will be transformed.”
The meditative sounds of flutes and chimes used to accompany the main character’s flashbacks to his pre-war youth makes for a nostalgic experience. The sounds are reminiscent of classic Khmer music, creating an element of remembrance while the past was being erased. This stands in stark contrast to the pop music I heard during my more recent time in Cambodia. The music from the film signifies its time and historical focus well, and given my personal experiences in Cambodia, it is interesting to note how the sound has changed from pre-war to post-war.
In having seen and frequented the places the director takes us in the film, including the locations of atrocities which took place not long ago, I can’t help but wonder what his intent was in creating such a film. Was it more for personal healing and reconciliation, seeing that he’d lost his entire family to the Khmer Rouge? Or was he speaking to a particular audience, as the last line of the film declares: “This missing picture I now hand over to you so that it never sees to seek us out.” By saying this, does he want to pass the message along to someone in particular?
Intriguingly, The Missing Picture was submitted to be nominated for an Academy Award in the U.S. this year. Was the director trying to appeal to the West in doing so? There were specific scenes that speak to an international audience. One particular scene in the film, which takes place between the start of Pol Pot’s seizing power and the sending of thousands of citizens to labor camps, involves a storyteller telling a tale. The story recounts a Khmer family gathered around a television set watching the U.S. space shuttle rocket launch into space, thus marking history with the first person to land on the moon. The storyteller was later executed for telling that tale of inspiration. There was also a scene that talked about the Americans dropping bombs on Cambodian soil, which sparked the poor majority to join “the revolution” under false information. Is it meant to imply that the U.S. in some way responsible for what happened? What is the sentiment such scenes are intended to evoke? One scene in particular resonated with me. It depicts starving Khmer people working in labor camps to fill sacks of rice, not to feed themselves, but to feed the “revolutionary” leaders and to ship the rice abroad. Was that rice being shipped to the U.S.? Did the U.S. have any idea of what was occurring at the time a world away? Or were we left in the dark? Such scenes led me to believe that the director included them for a reason: I believe that they speak to a particular audience, perhaps to an international audience. The additional fact that the film is narrated in English reinforces my conclusion. Was the medium of film used to provoke interest in the topic, as is often done with pop culture? If the director is targeting a certain audience, why is he doing so? For the purpose of looking towards the future? The ending leaves a heavy brick of responsibility on the viewer’s heart by stating he wants to hand it over to “you” without explaining the purpose. To learn from what happened? To prevent such tragedy from happening again? Or was the film meant to bridge the gap between the older Khmer generation and the youth? Perhaps with the use of clay, the director could focus on a young audience. Through clay, he could turn a horrific nightmare of a time into something comprehensible for them. Maybe more than recognition from the West, he wanted the message to reach the youth.
Without a doubt, the war has completely changed and reshaped the country, leaving major impacts for the future. The question is what the people of Cambodia will choose to do with them. Is that why Rithy directs our attention to this? Rather than being an isolated chapter of the past, he draws out the ways in which events are connected. Perhaps his overall intent in sharing this film is for everyone to do their part to ensure that history does not repeat itself.
Source of documentary poster, see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:The_Missing_Picture_2013_poster.jpg
More information on the documentary: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Missing_Picture_(film)
Please contact Professor Liang if you wish to contribute to The North Star Reports — HLIANG@CSS.EDU
For all of the North Star Reports, see http://NorthStarReports.org
The North Star Reports: The Middle Ground Journal’s collaborative outreach program with K-12 classes around the world. We acknowledge North Star Academy of Duluth, Minnesota as our inaugural partner school, and the flagship of our K-12 outreach program. We also welcome Duluth East High School and other schools around the world. The North Star Reports has flourished since 2012. For a brief summary, please see the American Historical Association’s Perspectives on History, at:
The North Star Reports will share brief dispatches from our student interns, particularly from those who are currently stationed, or will soon be stationed abroad. Student interns have reported from Mongolia, Southern China, Shanghai, northeastern China, The Netherlands, Tanzania, Ireland, England, Finland, Russia, and Haiti. We also have students developing presentations on theatrical representations of historical trauma, historical memory, the price individuals pay during tragic global conflicts, and different perceptions of current events from around the world. We will post their dispatches, and report on their interactions with the North Star Reports students and teachers.
Hong-Ming Liang, Ph.D., Chief Editor, The Middle Ground Journal, Associate Professor of History and Politics, The College of St. Scholastica, Duluth, MN, USA
(c) 2012-present The Middle Ground Journal. See Submission Guidelines page for the journal’s not-for-profit educational open-access policy.
20 responses to “Cambodia: “I seek my childhood like a lost picture” — Review of the Documentary The Missing Picture — The North Star Reports, sponsored by The Middle Ground Journal. By Cait Greeley”
Reblogged this on Professor Liang 梁弘明教授.
Thank you for sharing this article! I have never actually heard of this film before, but I am interested in seeing it now. Your depictions of what took place in the movie were so detailed, I was completely enthralled when reading this. I really enjoyed your thoughts at the end concerning your ideas behind what the director’s intentions were for who the audience is, why the director used clay, and what the director meant by the fews comments made at the end. These ideas are intriguing, and I am sure your are on the right track. Perhaps by making this film in English, the target audience are people who are unaware of this situation who need to be informed? Using the media is an interesting method for informing the public, as well as reaching out to a wider audience when you are in need of help. Was this movie in theaters, or did you stumble upon it, or was it shown to a class of yours? Thanks again!
This article is incredible and the film sounds amazing. I am shocked how the director made a film with characters made of clay into such an inspirational, award winning film. I also do believe that his intent of creating this film was to ensure history does not repeat itself.
This was an incredible and wonderful article; reading about the film definitely makes me want to see it! I find it exceptionally intriguing that the director uses the clay figurines as representations of people – but I also think it is interesting that it looks like a film kids would watch though it holds more mature themes. Your article definitely piqued my curiosity, thank you for sharing!
This article was beautifully worded and painted a picture in my mind on what the author saw while watching this film. The use of clay actors and having other parts of the movie real fascinated me; I was also confronted with questions while pondering this, just like the author. The message seems to have a haunting effect on the viewer– I received an almost eerie feeling while reading how the movie ended. It is amazing to read a glimpse of what has occurred in Cambodia; my heart aches because of what these people have gone through, and hopefully things will only improve in Cambodia.
This was such a good article. I liked the way you used questions to think about why this film was made. There were so many possibilities and this article makes me want to watch the film.
This sounds like an incredibly difficult film to make but also sounds like the effort paid off. The film sounds like it has had a major effect on you when you watched it. I think the clay figures add to the horror of the film by making it seem so lifeless. It always eye opening to hear about what happens in countries other than mine because our media doesn’t cover it much. I’m glad that awareness is being spread. Thank you for sharing.
This sounds like a very interesting documentary to watch! I really enjoyed your analysis of the film maker’s intent in doing the film and what he was able to achieve when he completed it.
this article was really well written. I cant believe all the work and effort that was put into making the movie. I exspecially liked how descriptive you were when talking about the film. That makes me want to watch the film
I really liked this article. I couldn’t imagine the time and work that was put into making this movie. I felt that this article was interesting and I would like to see the film some day.
You explained this documentary very well, and my favorite part of this article was your questions at the end, all of which were great questions. Thank you for sharing history, and I will definitely be watching the missing picture in the near future. I will be keeping this article in mind while watching it.
The way that you explained the film was very graphic without being overly morbid. I really appreciated the descriptions of the scenes that stuck out to you as well. It paints a drastic picture of a dark time in history that I hadn’t known before. I think the ideas that were brought up about the use of clay and real footage included in the film were very interesting as well. It’s definitely a point in history that I hadn’t known and am interested to know more about.
I really enjoyed reading this. I have a good friend whose father lived in Cambodia and had to flee during the Khmer Rouge regime. You asked a lot of good questions which I liked, rather than just brushing over them. I don’t know a lot about this period in Cambodia’s history and think it’s worth learning more about.
This sounds like a very interesting film. With the actors being made out of clay figurines, it sounds like the film has an interesting concept. And being portrayed after such a dark time would be interesting given the concept. I would like to watch it sometime!
Great critic of the movie! At first I was hesitant about a claymation on the Cambodian Genocide because I did not believe that the horrors of the Khmer Rouge and Pol Pot could be represented in clay. However, as I continued reading the article I began to think that the director did this on purpose. As you mentioned, it may be because the director wants to reach the youth with this film. Very interesting article and critic of the film.
“The clay figurines are used as the actors in the film; I cannot determine if they are used to help lessen the horror story or if they actually heighten it. The film almost feels like it could be viewed by young children, yet it is dark enough for a mature audience.” I think this is very interesting idea you brought up and it is rare that a film can be both seen through the eyes of a child but also show a very adult situation. For example, it is very common for people to assume cartoons are mainly for children. While that is true for some films, anyone who has seen Grave of the Fireflies and other films like it, knows that this isn’t always this case. This movie seems to make an example of the idea that although it is not a real person on the screen, the human emotions are very real. Why do you think the director chose to use clay figures instead of real people? What other messages could these figures represent?
I have not seen the film, yet. But it seems to have a lot of power and interest in a lot of people. Using the clay figures was a unique feature from reading the story.
At first I was a little skeptic about this film you are describing and how interesting it actually is, however as I continued to read I found it very intriguing. They way you describe how the director of the film uses art (the clay figurines) is a very different approach but it seems like he did an amazing job. Reading this makes me want to watch this because I it seems like an interesting and educational film.
Very good description of the film, sounds like an interesting way to show how history can affect people. you also ask a lot of great questions, which shows you really thought hard about the movie. I look forward to watching the film someday soon. thank you for your in depth comments
I really enjoyed this article. The movie you reviewed seems like a very powerful one. This seems like a very different movie, and i haven’t heard of one using clay figures.